Why Expanding the Supreme Court Matters: A Chat with an Undecided Voter

Stop scrolling and read this, undecided voter! 🙋‍♂️ I’m sure you’ve heard the debates around expanding the Supreme Court. Maybe you’re unsure about where you stand or simply curious about the benefits of such a proposal. So, grab a coffee, sit back, and let’s chat.

Understanding the Supreme Court’s Current Situation

First things first, let’s talk about what the Supreme Court is right now. It’s a group of nine justices, and they have the final say on crucial issues ranging from reproductive rights to climate policy. Given the lifetime appointments of these justices, the court’s composition can influence American policy and life for decades.

But here’s the catch: the number nine isn’t written in stone. In fact, the Constitution doesn’t specify a fixed number of justices for the Court. Over our history, we’ve seen the Court vary from five to ten justices.

Why Change the Current Set-Up?

You might be asking, “If it’s been working so far, why change it?” Well, the key is balance. Over the years, the nomination process has become increasingly partisan, which affects the Court’s neutrality. The addition of new justices could be a way to bring balance back.

1. Restoring Balance and Fairness

By expanding the Court, we can counteract the imbalances that have recently emerged. Imagine a situation where one political party holds power for a short period and, due to circumstances, gets to appoint several justices. This can drastically sway the Court’s decisions for years, even if that party doesn’t remain dominant in other branches of government.

Expanding the Court can level the playing field. If both major parties know that court expansion is on the table, it might deter them from pushing through appointments in a hyper-partisan fashion. The aim isn’t to have a Court that’s biased in one direction or another, but rather one that genuinely represents the will and values of the American people.

2. Keeping Up with Modern Times

Another thing to consider: our nation has grown significantly in size and complexity since the Supreme Court was first established. A nine-justice system might have been efficient in the past, but today, the vast array of issues brought before the Court might warrant a larger group of minds to deliberate.

3. Enhancing Representation

More justices could lead to a more diverse Court, representing a broader range of backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives. This diversity can lead to richer debates and more comprehensive considerations of the complex issues the Court handles.

4. Reducing Individual Justice Influence

With only nine justices, each one has immense power. Expanding the Court would dilute individual influence, making it less likely for a single justice to swing major decisions. It encourages a collective and collaborative decision-making approach.

The Common Counterarguments

But I can hear you wondering, “What about the arguments against expansion?” They usually boil down to two main points:

1. Setting a Dangerous Precedent: Critics argue that if we expand the Court now, what’s stopping the opposing party from doing the same when they come into power?
2. Politicizing the Court: Many fear that changing the number of justices makes the Court seem like a political tool rather than an independent branch.

Both concerns are valid. But here’s the thing: The Court is already political. The nomination and confirmation processes are driven by political motivations. Expanding the Court can be a way to correct and rebalance this inherent politicization, not exacerbate it.

A Vision for the Future

Imagine a Supreme Court that’s more reflective of our diverse nation, that’s equipped to handle the complexity of modern challenges, and whose decisions truly mirror the democratic principles upon which our nation was built.

If we approach Court expansion with care, bipartisan input, and an emphasis on ensuring long-term balance and fairness, it could be a game-changer. It’s not about tipping the scales in favor of one party but about ensuring the scales aren’t tipped unfairly to begin with.

So, dear undecided voter, I hope our chat shed some light on this topic. As you reflect on it, think not just about the present moment, but the kind of future you envision for our country. If that vision involves a balanced, fair, and representative Supreme Court, then expanding it might just be the way to go. 🇺🇸

Thank you for reading this Left Arrow Tees blog post. It is supported by our t-shirt store and if you have a few minutes we would love to have you shop around. Thank you!

Politics Shirts

Shop now